Thrifty and Frugal Living: Battle of the Sample Boxes: Ipsy Vs. Sample Society {June 2013}

Monday, June 17, 2013

Battle of the Sample Boxes: Ipsy Vs. Sample Society {June 2013}



 My subscription boxes have been coming early recently. Here is what I received for June:

*$10 a month 
*It was started by Michelle Phan (who is a Youtube Beauty Guru)
*Every month you receive a make-up bag with deluxe samples and full sized products 
 My June bag:


*Freeman Beauty Psssst! The TRUE Original Dry Shampoo (travel size= $2.99)
*Chella Ivory Lace Highlighter Pencil (full size= $18)
*J.Cat BeautySparkling Cream Palette ($4.49)
*NYX Rouge Cream Blush ($6)
*Starlooks Lip Pencil ($12)
*Referral Bonus: Baublebar Bracelet (this was listed for around $20, but has been removed from the site)
Total Value before Makeup and bonus Bag: $43.48

Initial Thoughts: Is it sad that I was jumping up and down over the travel sized cheap dry shampoo? This stuff is awesome and I literally ran out of my last travel size bottle of Psssst! last week. I was also really excited for the Chella Highlighting Pencil and the NYX Blush. I'm not a huge lip liner fan since my lips lack definition and I can't seem to figure out where to define them....but, this liner is a nice neutral color. I am going to give it a try. I thought the J.Cat Palette was pretty and loved the colors until I found out it's not eyeshadow. Apparently it is body glitter. I don't really have much use for body glitter. I will probably give it to my friends preteen daughter. As far as the bonus goes, this bracelet is CHEAPO looking. I can't believe that they sell it for $20+. I probably won't wear it and haven't decided what to do with it yet. It will probably tarnish shortly after someone wears it. I wish I had received another Urban Decay shadow instead. Ohh well.

 

 Sample Society (Please use code TFL99 if you sign up)
*$15 a month 
*Creation of Allure and Beauty Bar
*5 deluxe-sized samples
*$15 gift code to redeem on a $50 purchase - when any product from the brands you've sampled is included in your order.
*Expert beauty advice to accompany your samples from the editors of Allure
My June box:


*Stila Cosmetics Sheer Color Tinted Moisturizer SPF 20 in Fair ($34 for 1.7oz, 0.17oz= $3.40)
*Stila Cosmetics Lip Glaze in Grapefruit ($22, I think I received full size, but can't verify)
*Illume Desert Tulip Tin ($33.50 for full size, I received a small 1oz tin unknown value)
*Murad Age Reform AHA/BHA Exfoliating Cleanser ($35 for 6.75oz, 1oz= $5.19)
*Philosophy Hope in a Jar ($40 for 2oz, 0.4oz= $8)
Total Value before Candle Tin: $38.59

*Initial Thoughts: Yay, Stila!! I am not fond of tinted moisturizer, but I LOVE Stila lip products. This gloss is so pretty and works out great with my OCC lip tar. I am giving the tinted moisturizer another shot. I was excited for the candle, but it smells a little too flowery for me. I hope my Mom likes it. I already have (and don't use) Philosophy's Hope in a Jar, so I will probably send that to Mom too. The Murad Exfoliating Cleanser is awesome! I have been using it like crazy and I love the way it doesn't make my skin dry, but it makes it feel super clean.

*This Month's Winner: Honestly, neither box blew me away this month (ohh Gosh...am I becoming a beauty snob?). I would have to say Sample Society won even though they had the lesser overall value. I received all name brand products and a candle in Sample Society. The Ipsy brands were cheaper brands and the products were things that I would not buy (except that dry shampoo! You really have to try it!). In the end I will be using 3 products fully from each box that add up to $27 for Ipsy and a little over $30 for Sample Society. Still well worth my money. What did you get in your boxes?

 
Read my previous Battle of the Sample Boxes- 
Ipsy Vs. Birchbox:
Ipsy Vs. Sample Society:


Disclaimer: I pay for these subscriptions out of my own pocket. This is a completely honest post for the benefit of my readers. I am not in contact with the companies and I am not compensated in any way.

9 comments:

lemonlaurie said...

looks like some great stuff,I remember the dry shampoo!

Megan said...

These kinds of things would have been fun when I was younger and hadn't yet settled into products that work for me - and it probably would have helped me to find working products much more quickly!!

Theresa Wilson said...

I like these, they are fun to receive in the mail. However sometimes they don't have things that you are looking for or need. I do like the idea however. Thanks.

LAMusing said...

I'bve never even heard of sample boxes! Interesting...

Nathalie's Talons said...

I've heard of Ipsy but not the Sample Society.I like what you got in your Sample Society bag.

Some Lucky Dog said...

This sounds like fun and a good value, too!

CINDY B on rafflecopter

AEH said...

I've been hearing a lot about the beauty boxes lately. I've tried Blismo Box, which is a bit of everything but they are all natural and/or organic. I LOVED that box but I had to give it up when I stopped working.

vanessa mabel camba said...

I want that dry shampoo too! haha

Darlene Ysaguirre said...

I would of been indeed jumping up and down over travel size shampoo you can never have enough lol